This week’s FINRA law enforcement landscape continues to evolve with constitutional challenges mounting against the regulator’s authority. Several major developments have emerged, including significant fines for crypto-related violations, multiple industry bans, and a new initiative aimed at improving FINRA’s enforcement procedures.
- Constitutional challenges against FINRA’s authority gain momentum following the Supreme Court’s SEC v. Jarkesy decision, with investment advisor D. Allen Blankenship seeking injunction against disciplinary proceedings
- Thrivent Financial filed a petition with the D.C. Circuit Court challenging FINRA’s arbitration requirements, arguing the SEC lacks statutory authority to limit arbitration forum choices
- TradeStation Securities received an $85,000 fine for crypto communication violations related to inadequate disclosures about offerings not being through registered broker-dealers
- Multiple individuals received permanent industry bans in June for various violations, including refusal to provide information during investigations
- FINRA launched a comprehensive enforcement improvements initiative as part of its broader FINRA Forward program announced in April 2025
Growing Constitutional Challenges to FINRA’s Authority
Investment advisor D. Allen Blankenship has filed a lawsuit seeking to halt FINRA disciplinary proceedings, citing the Supreme Court’s recent SEC v. Jarkesy decision (603 U.S. 109, 2024). This case established that defendants are entitled to jury trials under the Seventh Amendment when facing civil penalties for securities fraud.
The challenge follows a similar pattern of broker-dealers questioning FINRA’s regulatory legitimacy. On June 2, 2025, the Supreme Court denied Alpine Securities Corporation’s petition for certiorari, which had challenged FINRA’s structure under the Appointments Clause and private non-delegation doctrine.
While Blankenship’s case was dismissed on procedural grounds without addressing the constitutional merits, these challenges represent a growing industry trend that leaves fundamental questions about FINRA’s authority unresolved despite the dismissals.
Thrivent Financial Challenges FINRA’s Arbitration Rules
Thrivent Financial for Lutherans and its subsidiary Thrivent Investment Management Inc. have petitioned the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals (Case No. 25-1047) to challenge FINRA Rules 12200, 12204(d), and 2268. These rules govern mandatory arbitration requirements for FINRA members.
The company argues that the SEC lacks statutory authority to limit arbitration forum choices. This creates particular tension for Thrivent given its unique status as a fraternal benefit society that offers variable insurance products through its subsidiary, which requires FINRA membership for regulatory compliance.
Thrivent had established an alternative dispute resolution process agreed to by its members, but FINRA rules require using only FINRA’s arbitration forum. The company’s legal argument centers on the position that regulators need express congressional authorization to restrict private arbitration rights.
TradeStation Securities Fined for Crypto Communication Violations
FINRA reached an $85,000 settlement with TradeStation Securities in July 2025 for violations occurring between July and September 2022. The enforcement action originated from FINRA’s 2022 targeted examination of crypto marketing practices.
The firm failed to clearly disclose that crypto assets were not offered through a registered broker-dealer and did not provide fair and balanced presentation of benefits and risks. These violations breached FINRA Rules 2210(d) and 2010, resulting in both censure and monetary penalties.
This represents the second similar settlement in 2025, following identical penalties issued in May. The communications allegedly confused retail investors about applicable regulations and protections, highlighting FINRA’s continued focus on crypto-related compliance issues.
Multiple Industry Professionals Receive FINRA Bans
FINRA’s August 2025 disciplinary actions report reveals several permanent bans from association with any member firm. These include:
- Jeffrey Alan Arbeit (CRD #6603428) – barred June 23, 2025 for refusing to produce information on private securities transactions
- Vincent Gilliard (CRD #7173084) – barred June 23, 2025 for refusing testimony regarding inaccurate registration information
- Michael Edwin Magruder (CRD #4579211) – barred June 27, 2025 for failing to provide information on alleged unauthorized customer loans
- Nicholas Stephen Coubrough (CRD #4678755) and John Casey Reap (CRD #1389009) – both barred June 30, 2025
Additionally, Donald Joe Everhart (CRD #2150508) received a more limited sanction including a $7,500 deferred fine, three-month suspension, and $100,000 restitution order. His case involved Regulation BI violations for inappropriate speculative bond recommendations that comprised 40% of a conservative investor’s net worth despite stated objectives of income and capital preservation.
FINRA Launches Enforcement Improvements Initiative
CEO Robert Cook announced a comprehensive enforcement initiative in July 2025 as part of the broader FINRA Forward program originally launched in April 2025. The program aims to enhance regulatory policies and practices across the organization.
Bill St. Louis, Head of Enforcement, is leading the improvement efforts with outside expert support from former SEC Commissioner Troy Paredes and Professor Paul Eckert. The initiative will assess enforcement governance, policies, processes, and inter-regulatory coordination to ensure effectiveness.
The FINRA Forward program focuses on three main areas: modernizing rules, empowering member compliance, and combating cybersecurity risks. This response to industry criticism and constitutional challenges demonstrates FINRA’s commitment to adaptation and building a culture of continuous improvement.
Sources
- morganlewis.com – Securities Enforcement Roundup – July 2025
- finra.org – Disciplinary Actions August 2025
- venable.com – Supreme Court Denies Certiorari to Decide FINRA Authority
- consumerfinancialserviceslawmonitor.com – FINRA Continues to Scrutinize Customer Facing Communications on Crypto Offerings
- leaprate.com – FINRA Fines TradeStation Securities for Misleading Crypto Communications
- finra.org – FINRA Announces New FINRA Forward Initiatives

0 Comments