The financial regulatory landscape continues to evolve with significant enforcement actions against major players. This week’s FINRA developments include multi-million dollar penalties against several prominent firms for violations ranging from excessive broker gifts to surveillance system failures and securities lending program deficiencies.
Top FINRA News This Week
- First Trust Portfolios hit with $10 million fine for systemic non-cash compensation rule violations including providing courtside basketball tickets worth $3,200 per pair
- Robinhood settles for $29.75 million plus $3.75 million in customer restitution over multiple regulatory failures affecting millions of investors
- Apex Clearing pays record $3.2 million penalty in first-ever enforcement action charging violations of FINRA Rule 4330 on securities lending
- Velocity Clearing fined $1 million after failing to review millions of trading alerts, including 5.2+ million that remained unexamined by early 2025
- Goldman Sachs assessed $1.7 million in penalties for IPO conflicts of interest and 14-year trade monitoring system deficiencies
First Trust’s $10 Million Non-Cash Compensation Violation
First Trust Portfolios agreed to pay a substantial $10 million fine following FINRA’s investigation into excessive non-cash compensation provided to broker-dealer representatives who sold their investment products. The violations occurred between 2018 and February 2024, spanning six years during which the firm’s wholesalers repeatedly circumvented FINRA Rule 2341.
The scale of the violations was significant. On more than 25 occasions, two First Trust wholesalers provided client representatives with courtside basketball tickets valued at $3,200 per pair. In another case, various wholesalers provided a single client firm representative with entertainment exceeding $31,000 in value over just 18 months, including tickets to more than 20 concerts and sporting events.
FINRA found that First Trust wholesalers had falsified internal expense records related to more than $650,000 worth of non-cash compensation. The firm’s reports to client firms omitted more than $500,000 worth of gifts, meals, and entertainment from the required disclosures. The settlement includes a three-year annual compliance certification requirement.
Robinhood’s $29.75 Million Settlement for Multiple Violations
Robinhood Financial and Robinhood Securities agreed to pay combined penalties of $29.75 million plus $3.75 million in customer restitution. The settlement addresses numerous regulatory failures spanning anti-money laundering programs, disclosure practices, and supervision of trading systems that collectively impacted millions of retail investors.
FINRA’s investigation identified critical deficiencies in Robinhood’s customer identification program, resulting in thousands of accounts being opened without proper identity verification. The firm also failed to adequately disclose its practice of “collaring” market orders by converting them to limit orders, leading to inferior price executions for many customers.
During the January 2021 market volatility, Robinhood’s clearing system experienced severe processing delays due to increased demand. Additionally, the firm failed to properly supervise paid social media influencers who posted potentially misleading promotions about the platform. These combined failures demonstrate significant gaps in Robinhood’s compliance infrastructure during a period of rapid growth.
Apex Clearing’s Historic $3.2 Million Fine for Securities Lending Violations
In a landmark enforcement action, Apex Clearing Corporation agreed to pay $3.2 million for violating FINRA Rule 4330 on securities lending – the first such action under this rule. Between January 2019 and June 2023, Apex operated a fully paid securities lending program that FINRA found violated core customer protection requirements.
The scale of the violation was extensive. Apex’s introducing broker-dealers distributed materials to more than 5 million retail investors, with approximately 850,000 customers having their securities borrowed without receiving any financial benefit. These customers were exposed to risks including higher taxation, loss of SIPC protection, and surrender of voting rights without compensation.
FINRA had previously penalized four introducing firms whose customers participated in Apex’s program, with those firms paying a combined $2.6 million including over $1 million in customer restitution. This enforcement action completes the regulatory response by holding accountable the clearing firm that designed and facilitated the program.
Velocity Clearing’s $1 Million Fine for Alert Review Failures
Velocity Clearing agreed to pay a $1 million fine after FINRA found the firm had failed to properly monitor customer trading for manipulative activities from December 2019 to the present. Despite receiving more than 40 inquiries about potentially suspicious customer activity, Velocity failed to enable its surveillance system’s prearranged-trading detection capability.
When the module was finally activated, it immediately generated more than 10,000 alerts that Velocity never reviewed. Later, the firm closed approximately 147,000 alerts (98% of total) without investigation, with staff sometimes clearing hundreds or thousands of alerts in a single day without proper review.
The problems persisted even after Velocity changed platforms in July 2023. The new system produced approximately 15.2 million alerts for potential market manipulation, with over 5.2 million remaining unreviewed by early 2025. FINRA found Velocity’s staffing inadequate, with a single person handling alert reviews for part of the period while juggling other responsibilities.
Goldman Sachs Fined $1.7 Million for IPO Conflicts and Surveillance Failures
Goldman Sachs agreed to pay approximately $1.7 million in combined penalties for separate violations involving IPO conflicts of interest and trade monitoring system deficiencies. The firm will pay $250,000 for IPO-related violations and $500,000 for surveillance system failures.
As lead underwriter in a July 2021 IPO, Goldman allowed 13.5% of the proceeds ($96 million) to repay a loan from a Goldman affiliate without an independent underwriter as required by FINRA rules. Between May 2021 and March 2022, the firm also permitted four individuals to perform investment banking activities while unregistered.
Most concerning was the duration of the surveillance system deficiencies. For 14 years (2009-2023), Goldman failed to include warrants, rights, units, and certain equity securities in its trade surveillance reports. This systematic gap meant that certain types of potentially manipulative trading activity went unmonitored for over a decade, a failure discovered during routine FINRA examinations.
Sources
fa-mag.com – First Trust Portfolios Fined $10M By Finra For Alleged Gift Violations
finra.org – FINRA Orders Robinhood Financial to Pay $3.75 Million in Restitution to Customers
mofo.com – Automated System Monitoring Failures Lead to $1 Million FINRA Fine

0 Comments